Tens of thousands of protesters marched in cities across the United States on Saturday to demand the Trump administration reverse an immigration crackdown that has separated children from parents at the U.S-Mexico border and led to plans for military-run detention camps.
Outside the White House, protesters waved 'Families Belong Together' signs and chanted 'Shame!' as religious leaders and activists urged the administration to be more welcoming of foreigners and to reunite families.
"The way they treat families, the way they treat immigrants, that's not America," said protester Aneice Germain of President Donald Trump's tough stance on immigration, a cornerstone of his 2016 election campaign and his presidency, Reuters reports.
Thousands of protesters in New York marched across the Brooklyn Bridge bearing signs with slogans such as 'Make America Humane Again' and 'Immigrants Are Welcome Here.' On the U.S.-Mexico border, demonstrators partially blocked a bridge connecting El Paso, Texas with Ciudad Juarez in Mexico.In Chicago, thousands gathered to march toward the offices of federal immigration authorities. "I’m here because families belong together," said Cindy Curry of Westchester, Illinois.A federal judge has ordered families be reunited and the administration asked the military to house immigrant families, leading the Pentagon to mull the construction of soft-sided camp facilities.
Organizers estimated 30,000 people had gathered in central Washington. The peaceful protest appeared to be the largest pro-immigration demonstration in the U.S. capital since at least 2010, when activists rallied to pressure then-President Barack Obama and Congress to overhaul the U.S. immigration system.
Trump says illegal immigration fosters crime and he implemented a 'zero-tolerance' policy in May to prosecute all immigrants apprehended for entering illegally. That led to the separation of more than 2,000 children from their parents, causing an international outcry.
In a rare retreat on an issue that fires up his conservative base, Trump on June 20 ordered officials to detain families together.
By: Ramzy Baroud (*)
In May, U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced the government's 'zero tolerance' policy at U.S. border crossings. It was a matter of weeks before the new policy began yielding tragic outcomes. Those attempting to unlawfully cross into the United States were subject to federal criminal prosecution, while their children were taken away by federal authorities, which placed them in cage-like facilities.
Expectedly, the policy caused outrage and was eventually reversed. However, many of those who have chastised the administration of President Donald Trump seem willfully ignorant of the fact that Israel has been carrying out far worse practices against Palestinians.
In fact, many within the American ruling classes, whether Republicans or Democrats, have been captivated with the Israeli model for decades. For years, U.S. pundits have praised not just Israel's supposed democracy, but also its security apparatus as an example to be emulated. Following the September 11, 2001 attacks, a renewed U.S. love affair with Israel's security tactics blossomed, where Tel Aviv raked billions of American taxpayers' dollars in the name of helping secure U.S. borders against perceived threats.
A new, even more appalling chapter in the ongoing cooperation was penned soon after newly-elected Trump declared his plan to build a 'great' wall at the U.S.-Mexico border. Even before Israeli companies jumped on the chance to build Trump's wall, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu tweeted approvingly of Trump's "great idea," claiming that Israel's own wall has been a "great success" for it "has stopped all illegal immigration."
Netanyahu and Trump
In the case of Israel, the word 'democracy' is hardly fitting. At best, Israel's democracy can be described as unique. The Jewish State's former Supreme Court President Aharon Barak was quoted as saying that "Israel is different from other countries. It is not only a democratic state, but also a Jewish state."
At a Tel Aviv conference earlier this year, Israel's divisive Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked offered her own version of Barak's assertion. "Israel is a Jewish state," she said. "It isn't a state of all its nations. That is, equal rights to all citizens but not equal national rights."
In order for Israel to preserve its version of 'democracy,' it must, in the words of Shaked, "maintain a Jewish majority even at the price of violation of rights."
Israel spins the concept of democracy in whichever direction allows it to ensure the dominance of the Jewish majority at the expense of Palestinians, the native inhabitants of the land, whose rising numbers are often seen as a 'demographic threat;' a 'bomb,' even.
Israel, to this day, has no formal constitution. It is governed by what it is known as 'Basic Law'. Having no moral code or legal foundation according to which the state's behavior can be judged, the Israeli parliament (Knesset) is, therefore, free to draft and impose laws targeting Palestinian rights without having to wrangle with such notions as these laws being 'constitutionally' challenged.
Moral and Legal Codes
One of the reasons Trump's family separation law at the border failed is that, despite flaws in its democratic system, the United States has a constitution and a relatively strong civil society that can utilize the country's moral and legal codes to challenge atrocious state conduct.
In Israel, however, this is not the case. The government invests much energy and funds to ensure Jewish dominance and to establish physical links between illegal Jewish settlements (built on Palestinian land in defiance of international law) and Israel itself. At the same time, it invests equal resources to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from their own land, while keeping their communities everywhere separated and fragmented.
The sad truth is that what Americans have witnessed at their southern border in the last couple of months is what Palestinians have experienced as a daily reality at the hands of Israel for the last 70 years.
The kind of separation and segregation that Palestinian communities endure goes even beyond the typical outcomes of war, siege and military occupation. It is something enshrined in Israeli law, crafted mainly to weaken, even break down the cohesiveness of Palestinian society.
For example, in 2003, the Knesset voted in favor of the 'Citizenship and Entry into Israel Law,' which placed severe restrictions on Palestinian citizens of Israel who were applying for family unification. When rights groups challenged the law, their efforts failed as the Israeli Supreme Court ruled, early 2012, in favor of the government.
In 2007, that same law was amended to include spouses from 'enemy states': namely Syria, Iran, Lebanon and Iraq. Unsurprisingly, citizens of some of those 'enemy states' were included in Trump's ban on citizens of mostly Muslim countries from entering the United States.
It is as if Trump is following an Israeli blueprint, fashioning his decisions around the principles that guided Israeli policies towards the Palestinians for many years.
Even the idea of caging children is an Israeli one, a practice exposed by rights group the Public Committee against Torture in Israel (PCATI).
The policy, which has allegedly been discontinued, allowed for the placing of Palestinian detainees – including children – in outdoor cages, even during severe winter storms.
The 'caging' of Palestinians, however, is an old practice. Today, the Israeli Apartheid wall separates Palestinians from their land and segregates between Arabs and Jews on racial grounds. As for Gaza, the entire Strip – which hosts 2 million people, mostly refugees – has been turned into a massive 'open-air prison' of walls and trenches.
While many Americans are relieved by Trump's decision to end the practice of family separation at the border, U.S. politicians and media are oblivious to the fate of Palestinians who have endured horrific forms of separation for many years. Even more troubling is the fact that many among Republicans and Democrats see Israel not as a liability to real democracy, but as a shining example to be followed.
(*) Ramzy Baroud is a journalist, author and editor of Palestine Chronicle. His latest book is ‘The Last Earth: A Palestinian Story.' Baroud has a Ph.D. in Palestine Studies from the University of Exeter and is a Non-Resident Scholar at Orfalea Center for Global and International Studies, University of California Santa Barbara.